Marsh | Rickard | Bryan

Marsh, Rickard & Bryan

FREE CONSULTATION 24/7

FREE CONSULTATION 24/7

Investigations: Many booster seats fail on side-impact safety

In February, the nonprofit investigative newsroom ProPublica produced a report on Evenflo, the manufacturer of the “Big Kid” booster seat. ProPublica found that Evenflo had designed its own side-impact crash test that was virtually impossible to fail and then advertised that the car seat was side-impact crash tested.

In real-world situations, the side-impact crashes simulated by Evenflo could cause a child to be seriously injured, ejected from the seat or even killed.

We highly recommend reading ProPublica’s report on Evenflo and the Big Kid booster seat. However, there have been further developments in the story. Now, a congressional subcommittee has found that these problems are widespread among booster seat manufacturers.

Lax safety rules may have allowed exaggerations

One thing to understand is that U.S. safety regulators have not established side-impact crash standards for child booster seats. These are car seats best used by children 40 pounds and larger who no longer fit in smaller, more protective car seats. Twenty years ago, Congress directed the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to enact standards for side-impact tests, but NHTSA has failed to do so.

The House Committee on Oversight and Reform’s Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy followed up on the ProPublica investigation to see if other manufacturers were relying on made-up side-impact tests and then using the results in their marketing.

Apparently, they were. The subcommittee probed Evenflo and other booster seat manufacturers, examining internal documents videos of safety tests. The findings led the subcommittee to urge NHTSA, the Federal Trade Commission, and state regulators to investigate possibly “unfair and deceptive marketing and unreasonable risks to safety” by the booster seat manufacturers.

“Our investigation revealed that booster seat manufacturers are more interested in leading parents to believe that their products are safe rather than ensuring that they actually are,” said the chair of the subcommittee.

For example, subcommittee investigators found that Graco, which also manufactures a child booster seat, gave a passing grade to their seat after a test the company had invented. The video of the test shows a child-size dummy being thrown far beyond the confines of the seat and placed in a “dangerously contorted position” after what was considered a mild side-impact collision. The actual result would likely be grave injury or death.

A Graco spokesperson said the company “stands behind its long record of safety” and “extensive testing methods that meet or exceed federal regulation.”

The subcommittee, however, concluded that Evenflo, Graco, Artsana, Britax, Dorel Juvenile and KidsEmbrace had all engaged in deceptive marketing when claiming their booster seats were successfully side-impact tested.

Meanwhile, NHTSA recently proposed raising the minimum weight for booster seats to 40 pounds, but it specifically said it would exclude booster seats from any new side-impact test requirements.

Is your child’s booster seat affected?

At this point, it is simply impossible to say whether your child’s booster seat is safe in side-impact crashes. As you can see, manufacturers have been claiming the seats pass side-impact tests but failing to specify that those tests are virtually impossible to fail.

If your child was injured in a side-impact crash, you should be aware that the car seat manufacturer could be partly at fault. Even though side-impact tests are not legally required, the manufacturer still has a duty to provide a product that is reasonably safe in all foreseeable circumstances.

Talk to an attorney who handles product liability to determine if you may have a claim.

i 3 Table of Contents

We listen. Your story matters to us.

We have a team of courtroom lawyers with a proven track record to help you tell your story. And we have the resources, the experience and the reputation to make sure you’re heard.

Tell Us About Your Case

Check Consent Box

Honored To Be a Part of Their  Story
"They took a case that others would have stayed clear of.."
I have the utmost respect for Rip Andrews and the lawyers at MRB Law. They took a case that others would have stayed clear of because the issue of state immunity was involved. Through determination and unwavering commitment they were able to a find resolution to an extremely difficult matter.
Nancy Owen
"They took a case that others would have stayed clear of.."
I have the utmost respect for Rip Andrews and the lawyers at MRB Law. They took a case that others would have stayed clear of because the issue of state immunity was involved. Through determination and unwavering commitment they were able to a find resolution to an extremely difficult matter.
Nancy Owen
"They...brought justice to my family through a multi-million dollar verdict ."
These lawyers took a complicated issue, revealed the truth in a way 12 jurors unfamiliar with the topic could understand, and brought justice to my family through a multi-million dollar verdict. They were able to relate my “invisible” medical condition to the jury better than I can to my own friends. And because of that, the jury hugged me and cried with me when it was all over. That meant more to me than any amount of money.
Caroline Malatesta
"They...brought justice to my family through a multi-million dollar verdict."
These lawyers took a complicated issue, revealed the truth in a way 12 jurors unfamiliar with the topic could understand, and brought justice to my family through a multi-million dollar verdict. They were able to relate my “invisible” medical condition to the jury better than I can to my own friends. And because of that, the jury hugged me and cried with me when it was all over. That meant more to me than any amount of money.
Caroline Malatesta
"Our relationship began as strangers but ended in friendship thanks to the compassion he showed ."
I can’t adequately put into words the appreciation I have for Mr. Derrick Mills and MRB Law. He was assertive in his fight for justice for our family during our time of tragedy. Mr. Mills is knowledgeable, passionate and a great communicator. Our relationship began as strangers but ended in friendship thanks to the compassion he showed. Thank you Mr. Mills for being a dedicated professional! Justice done right!
Dana Owens
"Our relationship began as strangers but ended in friendship thanks to the compassion he showed."
I can’t adequately put into words the appreciation I have for Mr. Derrick Mills and MRB Law. He was assertive in his fight for justice for our family during our time of tragedy. Mr. Mills is knowledgeable, passionate and a great communicator. Our relationship began as strangers but ended in friendship thanks to the compassion he showed. Thank you Mr. Mills for being a dedicated professional! Justice done right!
Dana Owens
Related Articles
How can a malfunctioning seat belt be fatal?
How can a malfunctioning seat belt be fatal?

Seat belts are one of the most important safety equipment inside vehicles; millions of people depend on them daily. This type of equipment has a dramatic impact on a person’s chances of survival in an accident. A malfunctioning seat belt can put drivers and passengers...

Common injuries resulting from defective toys
Common injuries resulting from defective toys

Toys are a natural and healthy part of growing up. They foster creativity and provide much-needed entertainment for children. However, not all toys are as healthy as others - some can even pose serious risks if they are defective. Defective toys create various...

The problem with recalls of unsafe baby products
The problem with recalls of unsafe baby products

When an American business voluntarily recalls one of its products, or the government forces it to do so, it's generally in reaction to reports that the product is unsafe. Sadly, it can take several injuries or even deaths at the hands of a negligently designed or...

Related Videos
Personal Account
Business Account
Investments
Insurance Services
Ohter Services
Debit Card
Credit Card

Your story matters to us

Tell Us Your Story